logologologo
  • (714) 547-5025
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • About Workers’ Compensation
    • What Is Workers’ Compensation?
    • What Does A Workers’ Compensation Attorney Do?
    • Types of Work Injuries
    • How Long Does a Workers’ Comp Case Take to Resolve in California?
    • When You Should Hire a Workers’ Compensation Attorney
    • Types Of Workers’ Compensation Benefits
    • How Workers’ Compensation Attorneys Get Paid
    • Do You Have a Workers’ Compensation Case?
    • Filing a Workers’ Comp Claim in California
    • Helping Injured California Workers
    • Have You Had a Career Ending Injury?
  • About
    • About Thomas F. Martin, PLC
    • Award Winning Workers’ Comp Lawyer
    • Fighting For Injured Workers’ Rights
    • Free Consultation
    • FAQs
    • News
  • Contact
logologologo
  • (714) 547-5025
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • About Workers’ Compensation
    • What Is Workers’ Compensation?
    • What Does A Workers’ Compensation Attorney Do?
    • Types of Work Injuries
    • How Long Does a Workers’ Comp Case Take to Resolve in California?
    • When You Should Hire a Workers’ Compensation Attorney
    • Types Of Workers’ Compensation Benefits
    • How Workers’ Compensation Attorneys Get Paid
    • Do You Have a Workers’ Compensation Case?
    • Filing a Workers’ Comp Claim in California
    • Helping Injured California Workers
    • Have You Had a Career Ending Injury?
  • About
    • About Thomas F. Martin, PLC
    • Award Winning Workers’ Comp Lawyer
    • Fighting For Injured Workers’ Rights
    • Free Consultation
    • FAQs
    • News
  • Contact
logologologo
  • (714) 547-5025
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • About Workers’ Compensation
    • What Is Workers’ Compensation?
    • What Does A Workers’ Compensation Attorney Do?
    • Types of Work Injuries
    • How Long Does a Workers’ Comp Case Take to Resolve in California?
    • When You Should Hire a Workers’ Compensation Attorney
    • Types Of Workers’ Compensation Benefits
    • How Workers’ Compensation Attorneys Get Paid
    • Do You Have a Workers’ Compensation Case?
    • Filing a Workers’ Comp Claim in California
    • Helping Injured California Workers
    • Have You Had a Career Ending Injury?
  • About
    • About Thomas F. Martin, PLC
    • Award Winning Workers’ Comp Lawyer
    • Fighting For Injured Workers’ Rights
    • Free Consultation
    • FAQs
    • News
  • Contact
  • (714) 547-5025
  • Workers’ Compensation
    • About Workers’ Compensation
    • What Is Workers’ Compensation?
    • What Does A Workers’ Compensation Attorney Do?
    • Types of Work Injuries
    • How Long Does a Workers’ Comp Case Take to Resolve in California?
    • When You Should Hire a Workers’ Compensation Attorney
    • Types Of Workers’ Compensation Benefits
    • How Workers’ Compensation Attorneys Get Paid
    • Do You Have a Workers’ Compensation Case?
    • Filing a Workers’ Comp Claim in California
    • Helping Injured California Workers
    • Have You Had a Career Ending Injury?
  • About
    • About Thomas F. Martin, PLC
    • Award Winning Workers’ Comp Lawyer
    • Fighting For Injured Workers’ Rights
    • Free Consultation
    • FAQs
    • News
  • Contact
by Thomas F. Martin
News, Workers' CompensationApril 14, 20210 comments

The Grand Bargain Faces Another Wrecking Ball

Picture credit: https://newint.org/features/2019/01/07/trade-turmoil-chance-justice

The “Grand Bargain” between employers and employees struck over 100 years ago in California was simple – employers could not be sued for injuries on the job in exchange for a “no-fault” workers compensation system with limited benefits and access to quality medical treatment.

Injured workers have honored their side of the deal. Employers remain protected from being sued for damages in Superior Court, even if they have been negligent. However, powerful business interests have continued to erode the already limited benefits injured workers with “caps” on benefits, methods to reduce Permanent Disability awards, and rationing medical treatment. Working conditions are supposed to be safe and sanitary.

Yet, even in 2021, new lows are reported.

Take, for example, what Amazon workers have reportedly endured – being forced to urinate in bottles to save time. While Amazon claims each fulfillment center has dozens and restrooms and employees are free to “step away from their work station at any time.” But former warehouse workers say restrooms can be a five- to 10-minute walk from their station, making it difficult to use the restroom in a 15-minute break. In addition, workers are written up if they run over their break time.

There has always been a tug of war between an employers’ profit motive and employees’ interests for fair wages, employee benefits, and a safe workplace. The California courts and legislature have served as the “referee” between these interests.

But a new threat to workers has emerged – and it aims to dismantle the very nature of the employee/ employer relationship. 

The most recent example of this threat was California’s Proposition 22, which allows certain employers to sidestep their legal obligations to pay their workers minimum wage, health insurance, unemployment benefits, and worker compensation by classifying them as “independent contractors.” Of course, the billion-dollar companies that got Proposition 22 passed (and spending 200 million dollars in advertising to make sure it did) promised that workers would do better by having the “freedom” to be independent contractors.

Of course, gig workers now realize they were duped. “It’s clear that as soon as Proposition 22 passed, it was open season to start cutting my pay” said Peter Young, a rideshare driver in Los Angeles. Young said the incentives offered to drivers before Proposition 22 “disappeared” after the voters passed it. Young’s experience is not unique to him. A University of California study in October of 2019 found that Proposition 22 only guaranteed a minimum wage of $5.64 an hour.

So, now the Grand Bargain faces two threats: the decades-old effort by employers to reduce the workers’ compensation benefits and Silicon Valley’s app-based efforts to enlarge the “gig” economy preventing workers from claiming employee status in the first place.

Next time, voters shouldn’t be so quick to believe the “win-win” hype of billionaires, “thought leaders,” and consultants who claim at TED talks that the market, instead of the government, has the best interests of workers in mind.

The most powerful institutions that California workers have to protect them are the legislature and the courts. Let’s not let the billionaire class take them away.

Sources:

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-drivers-peeing-in-bottles-union-vote-worker-complaints/

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/feb/18/uber-lyft-doordash-prop-22-drivers-california#:~:text=’I%20can’t%20keep%20doing%20this’%3A%20gig%20workers,fallen%20after%20California’s%20Prop%2022&text=Drivers%20and%20labor%20groups%20opposed,they%20make%20billions%20of%20dollars.

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/11/05/after-their-projected-victory-in-california-labor-law-fight-gig-companies-like-uber-and-lyft-eye-other-states.html

Tags:
Workers comp lawyer
New Study Reveals When Construction Workers Are At Most Risk For InjuryPrev
California's Workers' Compensation System: Achieving Social Justice?Next

Latest Posts

by Thomas F. Martin

Understanding Permanent Disability: Insights from a Workers’ Compensation Lawyer

When it comes to workers' compensation and disability benefits, it's important to know about different types of disabilities. One type is called...

Understanding Permanent Disability: Insights from a Workers’ Compensation Lawyer

Workers' CompensationAugust 12, 2023
by Thomas F. Martin

Understanding Workers’ Compensation Cases: The Legal Standard of Proof

Introduction: When an employee gets injured at work or becomes sick due to work conditions, they may be entitled to workers' compensation benefits....

Understanding Workers’ Compensation Cases: The Legal Standard of Proof

Workers' CompensationAugust 8, 2023
by Thomas F. Martin

Workers’ Compensation: What You Need to Know

Workers' compensation is like a safety net for employees who get hurt at work or become sick because of work conditions. Employers pay an annual...

Workers’ Compensation: What You Need to Know

Workers' CompensationAugust 3, 2023
logo

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About
  • Explore
  • FAQ’s
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Orange, CA
  • Santa Ana, CA
  • Anaheim, CA

Address

2107 North Broadway
Suite 206
Santa Ana, CA 92706

Phone

714-547-5025

Find Us

The information appearing on this website are provided for informational purposes only, and do not constitute legal advice or opinions. Transmission or receipt of any information through this website shall not create or establish an attorney-client relationship, and do not act or rely upon any information appearing on this website without seeking specific and competent legal advice from an attorney. Laws are constantly changing, and the information appearing on this website may be outdated and inapplicable to your circumstances and are not guaranteed.

 

Testimonials found on this website are actual past client reviews of Thomas F. Martin PLC. We appreciate our clients and their willingness to share their experiences. Please keep in mind that these results do not constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of your legal matter.

 

DO NOT SEND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION THROUGH THIS WEBSITE since an attorney-client relationship will only be established by a written retainer of Thomas F Martin PLC, and in no other way. Each case is unique, therefore testimonials and endorsements do not constitute a guarantee, warranty or prediction regarding the outcome of your potential case. Required Notice: "Making a false or fraudulent worker's compensation claim is a felony subject to up to 5 years in prison or a fine of up to $50,000 or double the value of the fraud, whichever is greater, or by both imprisonment and fine".